| 2001 | Phil Durocher | Longtime Teacher |
| 2002 | Anna Louise McDonald Thering | Class of 1926 |
| 2003 | Jim Powell | Class of 1953 |
| 2004 | Bill Myler, Sr. | Longtime Supporter |
| 2005 | Earl and Sharon Campbell Hartman | Class of 1966 and 1965 |
| 2006 | Class of 1946 | |
| 2007 | Edna Konwinski | Longtime Teacher |
| 2008 | Fr. Don Henkes | Longtime Teacher and Priest |
| 2009 | Sally Schafer Wood & Sharon Henry Cook | Class of 1959 & 1967 - longtime SHA cooks |
| 2010 | Fr. Tom McNamara | Sacred Heart Pastor 1991-1999 |
| 2011 | 1969, 1970 and 1971 Girl's Basketball Teams | Pioneers of Female Athletics |
| 2012 | Coach Bob Utterback's 1965-1968 Boy's Basketball Teams | |
| 2013 | John Johnson, Janet Johnson Patrick, Kathleen Gallager Mellon and Dianne Jensen Morey | Class of 1962, 1963 and 1964 State Debate Champions |
| 2014 | Sharon Stangle Tilmann | Class of 1964 |
| 2015 | 1975 Boys State Championship Basketball Team | |
| 2016 |
Bryan Neyer | Class of 1986 |
2017
| Mick and Dorothy Natzel | Class of 1967 |
2018 | Frank Deni | Class of 1953 |
2019 | Jerel Konwinski | Parishioner |
| 2020-21 | Rick and Mary Beth Roberts | Longtime Teachers & Administrator |
| 2022 | Joe Grabowski | Former teacher
and coach of the 1970 & 1971 football champs |
